Tata Sons Controversy: The ongoing tussle over the control of the Tata Group has now taken a new turn. Late Ratan Tata’s younger brother Jimmy Naval Tata has finally broken his silence on the matter. 85-year-old Jimmy Tata usually lives a quiet life in Pune, away from the limelight. But now he has expressed his clear opinion on the group’s biggest issues. According to a report in the Economics Times, Jimmy Tata has endorsed N Chandrasekaran for a third term as the chairman of Tata Sons. Along with this, he has also supported the Reserve Bank (RBI) rule, under which Tata Sons is required to be listed on the stock market. Jimmy Tata’s move is against his half-brother Noel Tata’s stance.
Jimmy’s opinion differs from Noel Tata’s
Currently, there is a conflict between the Tata Sons board and Tata Trust Chairman Noel Tata on many issues in the Tata Group. Noel Tata wants Tata Sons not to be listed on the stock market. Apart from this, they are against making Chandrasekaran the chairman again. At a time like this, Jimmy Tata’s coming to Chandrasekaran’s favor and listing is quite significant. Jimmy Tata expressed this view in a conversation with a fellow trustee. That trustee later informed the other trustees of Jimmy’s views.
Oldest Trustee of Sir Ratan Tata Trust
Jimmy Tata has been a trustee of Sir Ratan Tata Trust (SRTT) since 1989. He is the longest serving permanent trustee of this trust. Apart from him, only Noel Tata and Jahangir Jahangir are life trustees in this trust. Jehangir, who lives in Pune, also keeps a very low-profile like Jimmy. Both have never spoken openly about the group’s controversy till date. Jimmy Tata Bai Hirabai Jamshedji Tata is also a trustee of Navsari Charitable Institution and Public Service Trust. Both these trusts are also part of Tata Trusts.
A share worth thousands of crores, yet distance from meetings
After Noel Tata, Jimmy Tata is the second largest individual shareholder of Tata Sons. He holds 0.81% or 3,262 shares in the company. According to investment bankers’ estimates, the shares are valued at Rs. 7,000 crore to Rs. 10,000 crore is between. Despite holding such a large stake, Jimmy refrains from attending Tata Trust meetings or voting. However, he is known to express his views in detail by writing letters to trustees and board members. In an interview in 2016, he gave a file of hundreds of such letters to newspaper reporters. It is not clear whether he sent such letters after leaving his Colaba apartment in Mumbai and shifting to Pune. He was last seen at Ratan Tata’s funeral functions in late 2024. Ratan Tata also named a portion of the family’s Juhu bungalow after Jimmy Tata in his will.
Expressed concern over declining levels of trust
Jimmy Tata has been closely monitoring all developments within the trust since Ratan Tata’s demise. In a recent conversation, he lamented the declining standards of institutions. He said that the trusts should return to the same principles and objectives for which they were established. Jimmy Tata also believes that only one member of the Tata family should be on the board of the trust. Many family members should not hold influential positions. He clearly said that these institutions are created to serve the country and build the nation. Hence their work should reflect public interest and charity rather than family interests. Let us tell you that Jimmy Tata is the younger son of Naval Tata and his first wife Suni Commissionerate. Whereas, Noel Tata is the son of Naval Tata and his second wife Simone Dunoyer.
The rules listed and the effect of Jimmy’s opinion
Tata Trust’s total stake in Tata Sons is about 66 percent. Of this, SRTT alone has a 23.56 percent stake. Therefore, the role of this trust is most important in decisions about the future of the group. RBI has placed Tata Sons in the category of upper layer NBFCs. According to the rules, a company has to be listed on the stock market within three years of falling into this category. Tata Sons applied to surrender its core investment company registration, which was rejected by the RBI. It remains to be seen whether Jimmy Tata’s opinion has an immediate impact on the current controversy, as the situation will not be fully clear until he comes to the SRTT meeting and votes.





