Why are foreign investors fleeing the Indian market? Not just inflation or taxes, this is the biggest reason

Foreign Investors: Foreign investors are constantly withdrawing their money from the Indian stock market. In March 2014, the share of foreign investors in listed companies in India was 22.1 per cent, which has now declined to 15.1 per cent. This is the lowest level in the last 17 years. So far this year, foreign investors have sold shares worth Rs 3 lakh crore from the Indian market.

This figure in the entire year 2025 will be Rs. 1.66 lakh crore is almost double the sales. Generally, AI, expensive valuations, crude oil prices and taxes are considered as the reasons behind it. There is some truth in these things, but no one pays attention to the biggest reason. This reason has less to do with the market, but with the way the country is governed. Over the past decade, power monitoring institutions within India have weakened from their previous records. Foreign investors have watched this change very closely.

The future of investment is determined by the strength of institutions

In the famous book ‘Why Nations Fail’, published in 2012, Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson argued that institutions play a greater role in a country’s prosperity than geography or culture. For this research, he also received the Nobel Prize in Economics in 2024 along with Simon Johnson. According to him, strong institutions mean rules that bind powerful people. These include courts with the courage to rule against the government, an independent media and equal opportunities for newcomers.

Also Read:  Big leap in Kotak Bank's earnings! Profits rose 26%, here are the highlights of the results

When these institutions are weakened, power becomes concentrated in a few hands. Due to which people close to the system start to benefit as compared to outsiders. In such a situation, development does not stop overnight, but its pace slows down. For investors, this is not a political issue, but a criterion for investing money. Acting courts or independent regulators may not show up in quarterly earnings, but they play a big role in the price investors pay today for the next 10 years of earnings.

A picture of the decline is revealed in the watchdog index

A ‘Watchdog Index’ was prepared to measure the strength of these monitoring bodies. This index tracks referees rather than players. It includes five areas such as control of power, independent courts, freedom of speech, independent civil society and prevention of corruption. It is constructed by combining 13 public dimensions from V-DEM, Freedom House, the Economist Intelligence Unit, including the World Bank’s Governance Indicators.

This compares India not with Switzerland, but with India’s own old record (average from 2003 to 2012). Between 1996 and 2014, this index remained stable between -0.06 to +0.07. But after this it began to decline, falling to -0.42 in 2025. The six weakest figures on record have come in just the last six years. Of the 12 parameters that have changed since 1996, 6 are at their lowest levels. Freedom of speech and civil society have declined the most, while the courts’ control of power scores have also fallen over the past year.

Also Read:  Indians are iPhone crazy! Apple India earns bumper jump, sales at Rs. 1.03 lakh crores

Why are investors hesitant amid a strong government?

A decline in this index does not mean that the Indian state has weakened. The government today is building better roads, collecting taxes better and running welfare schemes than a decade ago. According to the World Bank, government efficiency has increased since 2014. In August 2025, S&P upgraded India’s rating for the first time in 18 years.

The upgrade was given for fiscal discipline, credible monetary policy and robust growth. The real weakness is in the system that monitors the government. Rating agencies see the first part of the picture, but foreign equity investors are looking at the second part. In the six years to March 2015, foreign investors invested an average of Rs. 1 lakh crore was invested. But in the following eleven years this figure decreased to around Rs. 6,000 crore has been reached.

Where does India stand compared to other emerging markets?

Compared to other countries in the MSCI Emerging Markets Index, India kept up with everyone until 2014, but then fell behind. The average for emerging markets is 0.14 below its normal level, while India is three times more, or 0.42 below. That means one-third of India’s decline is part of the global trend, but two-thirds of the decline is India’s own.

70 percent of emerging markets funds are invested in China, Taiwan and Korea, with a score of +0.03. Among the 24 markets in the index, only Turkey (-0.93), Mexico (-0.69) and Hungary (-0.67) fell more than India. India is fourth in this reduction. The impact of a deep recession is illustrated by the example of Turkey, where its shares are trading one-third cheaper than the average. On the other hand, AI business hubs Taiwan (+0.26) and Korea (+0.06) are above their normal levels.

Also Read:  What is 'Permanent Labor Certification Programme'? Trump has given a big blow to Indian tech companies by imposing ban

India is paying the price for poor oversight

Investors who invest money all over the world look at two things – the expectation of profit and the belief in that expectation. When monitoring institutions are weak, uncertainty increases. Regulators can balk, contracts can be difficult to enforce, or courts can take years to rule. To maintain investment in such an environment, investors demand higher returns, called the ‘country risk premium’. Higher earnings can offset this premium.

America (-0.30 to -0.44) fell more than India (-0.33 to -0.42) in this index last year. Yet investors ignored it as AI boosted profits for American companies. This year, earnings for S&P 500 companies are expected to rise nearly 30 percent. Corporate earnings in India are not growing fast enough to give investors the same confidence. Poor monitoring does not make the market uninvestable, it only increases investors’ demand for returns. When companies do not receive these returns due to strong earnings, stock prices tend to fall.

Enjoy reading Speaks Media?

Follow us on Google for the latest news.

Leave a Comment