Brainstorming on the future of Tata Sons! Noel will present an alternative plan at the board meeting

Tata Trust or rather Noel Tata is trying its best to block the listing of Tata Sons. There is a board meeting on 26th November. Tata Trust chairman Noel Tata may seek formal consideration of the ‘alternative restructuring proposal’ at the Tata Sons board meeting on November 26, according to people familiar with the matter. They say the proposal should be sent to the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) instead of proceeding directly with the listing process without properly examining other options.

He has also asked Tata Sons to include a detailed presentation in the agenda of the meeting. In this, it should be mentioned that the company Shapoorji Pallonji Group (SP Group) demanded Rs. 25,000 crore, which SP Group wants through partial monetization of its stake. He also made this request in the September 17 board meeting.

Noel Tata may also raise questions as to why there was a lack of transparency in handling RBI instructions. In particular, why was the message from the regulator (RBI) about the need for mandatory listing not immediately shared with all directors of the company (including himself)?

The ET report quoted sources as saying that there is little clarity on what information Tata Sons gave to the RBI, what stand the company presented and what response it received from the regulator. Noel Tata has not commented on this. This board meeting could turn out to be very noisy due to differing opinions on Tata Sons’ listing and stake monetization. The Trusts are being advised on legal matters by a firm named ‘Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas’.

Also Read:  Abolition of LTCG tax will cause a loss of 50 thousand crores to the government treasury! SBI estimates

There is no change in attitude

The ET report quoted sources as saying that there has been no change in attitude. We will closely examine all the details that are still unclear. To avoid this, the listing plan has to be changed in view of the alternative proposal that has been given.

It aims to move Tata Sons out of the category of ‘upper-layer NBFCs’ and ‘CICs’. Officials involved in the matter say that even if Tata Sons decides to go ahead with the listing following the RBI’s directives, there may be opposition on the issue at the company’s annual general meeting (AGM).

The RBI, in a letter dated November 16, told Tata Sons that it will have to comply with all regulations applicable to ‘upper-layer non-banking financial companies’ (NBFC-UL), “including listing conditions for the company.” The reply was given in reference to Tata Sons’ letter dated October 6, in which the company sought guidance from the regulator on compliance.

Also Read:  These 3 banks are offering higher FD interest than HDFC-SBI, you will get this much return on ₹1 lakh

Meeting of SDTT and TEDT will be held today

The meeting of Sir Dorabji Tata Trust (SDTT) and Tata Education and Development Trust (TEDT) has been fixed on November 20. SDTT consists of Noel Tata, his son Neville Tata, Bhaskar Bhat, Venu Srinivasan and Vijay Singh. In September, Tata Trusts (which owns 66% of Tata Sons) proposed to merge two group companies—Tata Electronics Systems Solutions and Tata Consulting Engineers—with a holding company.

Its objective was to change the regulatory category of the company and retain its ‘unlisted’ status. The proposal, submitted to the Tata Sons board and the RBI, called for Tata Sons to be converted into an ‘operating company’ that would have its own major business revenues. In addition, it will also continue to play its current role as the holding company of this $165 billion conglomerate.

Also Read:  India's nuclear mission will shine the fortune of these 3 companies! 20 lakh crore will be spent

What is Tata Trust’s argument?

The trusts’ contention was that the restructuring would bring Tata Sons out of the regulatory definitions of both NBFCs and CICs, thereby avoiding the need for a public listing. Under the proposed structure, the merged entity’s operating income as on March 31 would be Rs. 1.05 lakh crore, while income from financial assets will be Rs. 40,072 crore will be.

The share of operating income in total revenue would have been 64.3%, which would have put it outside the ‘core business’ criteria required for NBFC classification. According to the trust, its investment in group companies is Rs. 2 lakh crore would be about 88.5% of the total net assets, which is below the 90% limit of CIC classification.

Tata Sons may reject this alternative plan. The company contends that since the RBI has not allowed it to surrender the CIC registration, the company is now left with no particular option to avoid listing. The company has also taken a legal opinion from senior advocate Harish Salve, according to which it is the board’s responsibility to comply with the regulator’s instructions.

Enjoy reading Speaks Media?

Follow us on Google for the latest news.

Leave a Comment