GST on Corporate Guarantee: The Delhi High Court on Tuesday delivered a major decision on a tax dispute related to the corporate world. The Court clarified that a corporate guarantee given by a holding or group company to a bank or financial institution for a loan to its associate company (related person) would be treated as a ‘supply of service’. This will be taxed under the Central Goods and Services Tax Act (CGST Act) 2017. Even if no fee (consideration) is received in return, it will come under the ambit of tax. However, in a major relief, the Court read down the provision of fixed minimum deemed value of 1 percent per annum under CGST Rule 28(2), as arbitrary.
Big companies challenged in the High Court
In fact, many other companies including Sterlite Power Transmission, Jindal Stainless, Essar Power, GAIL (India), Essar Shipping, Future Brands, Hero Future Energy approached the court on this issue. The companies’ question was whether a corporate guarantee given by a parent company to a financial institution for the financial obligations of its subsidiary would be treated as a supply of service under Sections 7 and 9 of the CGST. Also, whether GST can be levied thereon at the rate of 1 percent under CGST Rule 28(2).
The undertaking of the guarantor’s risk is the same as the service supply.
A division bench of Justice Bharat Parashar along with Justice Anil Kshetpal heard the case. The bench said that corporate guarantee cannot be kept out of tax. Neither it can be treated as an ‘actionable claim’ under Entry 6 of Schedule III, nor can it be classified as a ‘security’ under Section 2(102) of the 2017 Act. The court explained that the assistance received by the subsidiary company from the holding company is ‘credit support’ and not a claim. A subsidiary does not have any rights against the guarantor under the guarantee. Conversely, if the guarantor pays the bank, the subsidiary company becomes its debtor and not a creditor. According to the court, the actual service is to bear the risk of default of the associate company. Also, the subsidiary gets the benefit of the guarantor’s goodwill. Therefore, under Section 2(93)(c), only the subsidiary company will be treated as the recipient of this service.
A fixed rule of 1 percent is unconstitutional
The High Court held that Rule 28(2) made for valuation of corporate guarantees given between related companies is not inconsistent with Article 246A or 265 of the Constitution. But where the rule makes the ‘deemed value’ of 1 per cent per annum a fixed minimum limit which cannot be varied, it becomes arbitrary. This violates Article 14 of the Constitution. Hence the Court has struck down this fixed limitation. Now if the supplier proves a lower ‘open market value’ based on concrete evidence, the same lower value will be considered instead of 1 percent. However, the fact of non-payment of an agreed amount or fee between the companies shall not be considered as evidence. The Court held the provisions of Rule 28(2) valid. Also, the court dismissed all show cause notices and orders issued against its decision.
How will guarantee be taxed?
The High Court has also clarified the position regarding the calculation of tax. The court held that the tax would be calculated for the entire guarantee period at the time of supply. However, if the tax department wishes, it can facilitate recovery in annual installments. The court has clarified three important things as per the dates.
- Guarantees made before July 1, 2017 will not attract tax, unless they are renewed, extended or enhanced after that date.
- Guarantees given between July 1, 2017 and October 25, 2023 are taxable, but will be valued as per the rules applicable at that time. Rule 28(2) or the scale of 1 per cent shall not apply to them.
- Rule 28(2) shall apply only to an undertaking given, renewed or extended on or after 26th October, 2023.
Along with this, the court has directed the concerned authorities to give full opportunity to the companies to be heard. After this, determine the tax liability afresh as per this decision of Tuesday.





