Finn Wittrock takes on the role of American chocolate pioneer Milton S. Hershey in Hershey, a new biographical drama that explores the businessman’s rise from repeated failures to building one of the world’s most recognizable chocolate empires.
However, the film is receiving criticism for presenting an overly polished version of its subject’s life. The Hollywood Reporter’s review describes the production as a sickly sweet biopic, questioning whether its carefully presented story does justice to the complexities of Hershey’s legacy.
Directed by Mark Waters, the film also stars Alexandra Daddario as Catherine “Kitty” Hershey. It follows the couple’s personal relationship, business ambitions and efforts to create a lasting legacy through education and philanthropy.
Finn Wittrock Stars as Milton Hershey in New Biographical Film
Wittrock portrays Milton Hershey, the entrepreneur whose name became synonymous with American chocolate. The story follows his journey from a difficult childhood in rural Pennsylvania to his determination to establish a successful confectionery business.
The film begins in the 1870s, introducing audiences to Hershey’s early family struggles and his experiences growing up in a Mennonite community. The death of his younger sister and his father’s departure become important moments in the character’s early life.
As an adult, Milton faces repeated business disappointments while trying to establish himself in the confectionery industry. His determination to develop affordable chocolate eventually becomes central to the story.
Wittrock brings an earnest and determined quality to the character, portraying Hershey as a man driven by ambition, optimism and a belief in his business vision.
What Is The Hollywood Reporter’s Review of Hershey Saying?
The Hollywood Reporter’s review, written by Frank Scheck, raises concerns about the film’s approach to telling Milton Hershey’s story.
Rather than presenting a complicated portrait of a successful businessman, the biopic frequently makes its central character appear almost entirely admirable. The review criticizes the movie for smoothing over difficult moments and making its dramatic conflicts feel predictable.
One of the biggest concerns is the way the screenplay handles setbacks. Business failures and personal challenges appear throughout the narrative, but their resolutions often arrive without enough dramatic tension.
This approach makes it difficult for audiences to feel the full impact of Hershey’s struggles. The film moves through important milestones in his life without always exploring the emotional consequences of his decisions.
The review also questions the production’s close relationship with the Hershey brand. Because the film was produced in partnership with Hershey-related entities, its presentation of the company’s founder invites questions about how much historical complexity the storytelling is willing to explore.
Alexandra Daddario Plays Catherine Kitty Hershey
Alexandra Daddario appears opposite Wittrock as Catherine, widely known as Kitty, Milton Hershey’s wife.
Her character plays an important role in the emotional development of the story. Kitty supports Milton through his professional difficulties while helping shape the couple’s shared vision for their future.
The film also explores how Kitty’s illness changes their priorities. As Milton’s business ambitions develop, the couple begins thinking about how their wealth could benefit future generations.
Daddario brings warmth to the role, providing an important emotional presence in a story that sometimes struggles to develop its dramatic moments.
Her performance helps establish the personal relationship at the center of the film, even when the screenplay does not give the characters enough emotional depth.
Hershey Movie Explores the Chocolate Empire’s Origins
The film traces Milton Hershey’s journey through several stages of his professional life, including his early experiences in candy-making and his repeated attempts to establish successful businesses.
His eventual success in chocolate manufacturing forms the central business storyline. Rather than focusing only on the creation of a famous company, the narrative also examines the couple’s ambitions beyond commercial success.
A major part of the story concerns their philanthropic vision and the development of an educational legacy for children.
Milton Hershey’s connection to Milton Hershey School remains an important part of his historical legacy. The film uses this aspect of his life to explore the idea that financial success can create opportunities beyond business.
However, critics have questioned whether the movie gives enough attention to the more complicated aspects of the historical figure and the institutions associated with his name.
Mark Waters Directs Finn Wittrock and Alexandra Daddario
Mark Waters directs the biographical drama, bringing a different type of storytelling to a project that combines business history, romance and family drama.
Waters is known for directing popular films including Mean Girls and Freaky Friday. His experience with character-driven entertainment gives Hershey an accessible presentation, although the subject matter demands a more detailed historical approach.
The supporting cast includes Alan Ruck, Richard Kind, David Costabile and Heléne Yorke. Their performances help bring additional characters from Milton Hershey’s personal and professional world into the story.
The film’s period setting also plays an important role in recreating the historical environment surrounding Hershey’s rise.
Despite its strong cast and recognizable subject, the central criticism remains the screenplay’s reluctance to explore the more difficult parts of its protagonist’s story.
Hershey Movie Cast and Release Date
Hershey is a historical biographical drama directed by Mark Waters and distributed by Angel Studios.
The movie is scheduled for a nationwide US theatrical release on November 25, 2026, ahead of the Thanksgiving holiday. Its runtime is approximately 110 minutes, and it carries a PG rating.
The principal cast includes:
- Finn Wittrock as Milton S. Hershey
- Alexandra Daddario as Catherine Kitty Hershey
- Alan Ruck as Henry Hershey
- Richard Kind as Joseph Royer
- David Costabile
- Heléne Yorke
- Francesca Faridany
The production brings together the story of one of America’s best-known confectionery entrepreneurs and the personal relationship that helped shape his legacy.
Why Hershey’s Historical Story Is More Complicated Than Its Movie Portrayal
Milton Hershey’s life offers material for a much broader historical drama than a straightforward business success story.
His journey involved financial setbacks, ambitious business decisions, the development of an industrial community and a philanthropic vision centered on education.
However, the history surrounding the Hershey business and its institutions also includes difficult questions about labor relations and the school’s historical racial admission policies.
These subjects provide important context for understanding the legacy associated with the Hershey name. Critics have questioned the film’s limited engagement with such complexities.
For a biographical film based on a real historical figure, the challenge is balancing an inspirational narrative with an honest examination of the subject’s wider impact.
That tension sits at the center of the critical response to Hershey, even as Wittrock and Daddario bring recognizable performances to the production.





