Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman is facing mixed opinions on India’s equity capital gains tax. While economists are advocating retaining the tax, industry leaders and foreign investors are calling for its abolition or a separate exemption for foreign funds. The differences have come to light at a time when India is trying to attract foreign investment again after a long period of sell-off. The government will now have to decide whether the potential benefit to the market and currency from granting the tax exemption outweighs the loss in government revenue due to the exemption. Apart from this, the government also aims to ensure that the tax structure across different asset classes remains roughly the same.
What do economists say?
In the first pre-budget consultation meeting with economists on Monday, most of the participants advised Nirmala Sitharaman to reduce long-term capital gains tax (LTCG) on equity. According to a PTI report, a source said that most economists present at the meeting were of the opinion that there should be no reduction in long-term capital gains tax.
According to the report, economists believe that the economy is showing early signs of recovery (green shoots), with private investment picking up and government spending on infrastructure supporting both public and private sector activities.
He appreciated the government’s fiscal prudence and low inflation rate. Also, he suggested measures to support micro, small and medium enterprises (MSME) and labour-intensive sectors, so as to create more jobs.
The advice is against the demands of Dalal Street and industry associations that the tax be scrapped. Global investors have also demanded separate rules for foreign portfolio investors (FPIs). Their argument is that foreign investors in many emerging markets are exempted from LTCG on equity.
What do investors want?
Currently, listed equity and equity mutual funds in India when the profit is Rs. Above 1.25 lakh attracts LTCG tax of 12.5%. For an investment to be considered a ‘long-term capital asset’, it must be held for more than 12 months. Short-term gains from equity sold within 12 months are taxed at 20%.
People associated with the industry have demanded that the LTCG tax should be abolished or its rate reduced for FPIs (Foreign Portfolio Investors). Another suggestion is to calculate foreign investors’ profits in US dollars, thereby benefiting from some ‘indexation’ against currency fluctuations.
Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) Chairman Ravi Agrawal said on Monday that the finance ministry is reviewing various aspects of capital gains tax on equity. Any changes to this will be announced in the Union Budget 2027-28.
Last month, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman herself admitted that LTCG has become a hot topic among domestic and foreign investors. He also said that the changes made in 2024 were aimed at bringing different asset classes ‘at par’, so that investors do not choose one investment over another just to save tax.
What does the SBI report say?
- On the other hand, it is easy to argue in favor of retaining this tax, as equity LTCG (Long Term Capital Gains) has become an important source of revenue for the government.
- Jefferies estimates that equity LTCG in FY2025 will reach Rs. 1.3 lakh crores can be earned. Including the Securities Transaction Tax (STT), equity tax accounted for 8% of total direct tax collections that year and 5% of total gross tax revenue.
- SBI Research argues that these revenue figures should be seen in the context of market performance. In FY 2025 Rs. 1.3 lakh crore collection was the result of good returns from the stock market in the previous year.
- According to SBI Research’s model, equity LTCG in FY 2026 will generate around Rs. 1 lakh crore and in FY 2027 Rs. 40,000 to 50,000 crores is estimated. SBI Research says that if LTCG is scrapped, the government can make up for the potential revenue shortfall.
- The report also suggests some other options instead of removing it altogether. Inflation adjusted Rs. 1.25 lakh, reducing the tax rate on investments held for more than two or three years or completely abolishing LTCG on investments held for more than three years.
- Another option could be to reduce the LTCG rate and simultaneously increase the STT (Securities Transaction Tax). SBI Research estimates that a 50% increase in STT in FY 2028 would generate around Rs. 45,000 crores in revenue.
- It also suggests that investors should be allowed to defer payment of LTCG tax if they reinvest the mutual fund redemption amount in another eligible equity mutual fund within 90 days.
Will tax cuts bring back FIIs?
- Investors’ concerns are not limited to tax rates. Foreign equity and capital inflows to India have seen a sharp decline. Jefferies says that by April 2025, the total withdrawal from the equity market by FPIs, foreign promoters and foreign private equity investors has reached $110 billion.
- An analysis of 70 large emerging market funds (with total assets of $380 billion) shows that the level of investment in India is 0.3 percentage points ‘underweight’ compared to the 10-year average (which was 2.2 percentage points ‘overweight’).
- According to a brokerage firm, a reduction in LTCG (Long Term Capital Gains Tax) on equities could improve market sentiment and also support the rupee. Large-cap stocks and sectors where foreign investors have sold heavily may benefit the most.
- Since October 2024, the highest FPI withdrawals from the financial sector have been $16 billion. After this, $10 billion has been withdrawn from the IT sector and $10 billion from the consumer staples (daily consumer goods) sector.
- According to Jefferies, sectors such as banking, energy, utilities and real estate could benefit when foreign investment flows return. The company is preferring large-cap stocks over mid-cap stocks.
- It says large-cap stocks have underperformed in 2026 and are now valued at 23 percent below their 10-year average (at a discount).
- The recent tax exemption granted to foreign investors in government bonds has also given some positive signals in favor of investors. After this relief, FPI investment in the debt market increased to $9 billion during June and July 2026. Jefferies believes that a reduction in LTCG on equities could also lead to a similar improvement in market sentiment.
Tax is not the main reason for FPI
- A separate analysis by JM Financial shows that capital gains tax is only a minor factor in determining foreign inflows. In the 24 months to September 2026, FIIs (foreign institutional investors) sold $59 billion in Indian equities.
- If October’s outflow (withdrawal of capital) is also included, this figure becomes approximately $64 billion. It was the longest and largest selloff ever in the brokerage firm’s 20-year dataset.
- JM Financial compared monthly FII investment data with GDP growth, interest rate differentials, earnings growth, valuations, rupee movements, oil prices and capital gains tax.
- The findings are that GDP growth has almost no correlation with FII investment, while ‘carry’ (interest rate differential) and earnings growth have a very modest positive correlation. Valuation affects investment figures with a delay of four to five months.
- At the same time, oil prices act like a ‘threshold’ (limit point). Since 2016, when Brent crude prices averaged above $105 a barrel, FIIs sold in six out of seven months, with average withdrawals of $4.1 billion per month. Conversely, when Brent prices remained below $75 per barrel, the average monthly investment was positive.
- The brokerage estimates that if the LTCG (Long Term Capital Gains Tax) is removed, annual dollar returns for foreign investors could increase by around 2.2 per cent. But, if the market’s P/E multiple returns to its 10-year average level, it could contribute around 24 percentage points.
- This shows that tax cuts can improve the investment climate, but they may not be more important than factors such as valuations, oil prices, currency movements and global risk appetite.
Sitharaman’s attempt to balance
Therefore, the government has two different contentions. Economists want the current tax structure to remain in place, so that fiscal discipline is maintained and equities are not given preferential treatment over other assets. On the other hand, investors argue that compared to other emerging markets, India is at a disadvantage in terms of investment because foreign investors there do not have to pay any capital gains tax on equity.
The tax cut could bolster market sentiment, bring some foreign capital back into large-cap stocks and also support the rupee. But, the data also shows that oil prices, valuations and global conditions have a much deeper impact on FPI investment than just tax changes. As the government is already reviewing capital market levies, this decision could prove to be an important signal for the market in Budget 2027.





