South Carolina: A South Carolina judge has rejected Alex Murdaugh’s attempt to dismiss the murder charges against him, ruling that disputed testimony about blood-spatter evidence and shotgun ammunition does not invalidate the original indictment.
Circuit Court Judge Debra R. McCaslin issued the decision on November 20, 2026, clearing the way for Murdaugh’s retrial over the 2021 killings of his wife, Margaret “Maggie” Murdaugh, and younger son, Paul Murdaugh.
Murdaugh’s defense team argued that investigators provided misleading information to a grand jury when prosecutors initially sought the murder charges. The attorneys said those claims undermined the legal basis for the indictment.
The dispute centers on testimony from former South Carolina Law Enforcement Division (SLED) investigator David Owen, who discussed alleged blood spatter on a T-shirt Murdaugh wore on the night of the killings.
Defense attorney Jim Griffin argued that Owen told grand jurors the shirt contained blood-spatter evidence linking Murdaugh to the crime, despite an earlier laboratory report finding no human blood in the tested samples.
The defense also challenged statements about shotgun ammunition recovered from the Murdaugh family property. Owen allegedly described ammunition combinations that matched those used in the killing of Paul, but defense attorneys said the recovered firearms did not support that account.
In her ruling, McCaslin acknowledged serious problems with the evidence presented to the grand jury. However, she determined that the remaining evidence was sufficient to establish probable cause for the charges.
The judge said the disputed blood-spatter and ammunition testimony would not have changed the legal basis for the indictment, even if the challenged statements were excluded from consideration.
McCaslin also sharply criticized Owen for failing to account for a laboratory report before presenting his testimony. She warned that investigative oversights of this nature could undermine public confidence in the criminal justice system.
However, the judge found insufficient evidence that Owen intentionally fabricated information or that prosecutors engaged in misconduct. She said the defense could challenge inconsistencies in the investigation during the upcoming trial.
Prosecutors maintained that the investigator’s statements reflected his understanding of the evidence at the time. They also argued that additional forensic testing supported the state’s blood-spatter interpretation.
The ammunition dispute remains another major issue for the defense. Prosecutors acknowledged that Owen’s description may not have been precise, but argued that inaccuracies did not establish deliberate deception.
The case dates back to June 7, 2021, when Maggie and Paul Murdaugh were found shot to death at the family’s Moselle hunting property in Colleton County, South Carolina.
Alex Murdaugh was convicted of both murders in March 2023 and sentenced to life in prison without parole. However, the South Carolina Supreme Court overturned those convictions in May 2026 after determining that former Colleton County court clerk Becky Hill improperly influenced jurors.
The overturned convictions resulted in a new trial, rather than an end to the criminal case. Murdaugh continues to deny responsibility for the deaths of his wife and son.
Prosecutors have also pointed to a cellphone video recorded by Paul on the night of the killings. The footage captured Alex Murdaugh’s voice near the kennels, contradicting his earlier statements that he was not there.
Investigators have additionally highlighted Murdaugh’s financial troubles and alleged theft of millions of dollars from clients and his former law firm. Prosecutors have argued that his financial circumstances formed part of the motive behind the killings.
Murdaugh’s retrial is scheduled to begin April 5, 2027. The latest ruling means his defense cannot use the disputed grand jury testimony alone to secure dismissal of the existing murder charges before trial.





