Tomasz Kosowski Sentenced to Death After Judge Rejects Last-Minute Bid to Remove Him From Case

A Florida plastic surgeon convicted of murdering attorney Steven Cozzi was sentenced to death on Friday, November 20, 2026, after a judge rejected his last-minute attempt to remove the judge from his case.

Tomasz Kosowski, 47, submitted a written motion seeking to disqualify Pinellas County Circuit Judge Joseph Bulone just as his sentencing hearing was getting underway. The judge briefly left the courtroom to review the filing before returning with a written order and proceeding with the sentence.

The decision marked another dramatic development in a case that has drawn national attention because Kosowski represented himself throughout the murder trial and chose to have a judge, rather than a jury, decide his fate.

Tomasz Kosowski Receives Death Sentence in Steven Cozzi Murder Case

Judge Joseph Bulone imposed the death penalty after reviewing the aggravating and mitigating circumstances presented during the sentencing proceedings.

The judge found that prosecutors had established two aggravating factors in the murder of Steven Cozzi. Special counsel appointed to represent Kosowski’s interests during the penalty phase presented one statutory mitigating circumstance and five non-statutory mitigating circumstances.

However, Bulone determined that the aggravating factors outweighed the mitigating circumstances.

During the hearing, the judge said Kosowski had forfeited his right to live before formally ordering that he be sentenced to death under Florida law.

The sentencing followed a lengthy penalty phase that involved several court appearances. Prosecutors had sought the death penalty following Kosowski’s conviction for first-degree murder in September.

Also Read:  Virginia State Senator Louise Lucas Faces Indictment in Federal Investigation

Why Did Tomasz Kosowski Try to Disqualify Judge Joseph Bulone?

The latest courtroom development began when Kosowski submitted a written motion asking Judge Joseph Bulone to step aside from the case.

The filing was presented shortly after the November 20 sentencing hearing began. Bulone accepted the motion and temporarily left the courtroom to examine its contents.

Approximately 20 minutes later, the judge returned with a written order rejecting the request. He then moved forward with the sentencing proceedings.

The attempt came at a critical moment, as the court was preparing to determine whether Kosowski would receive life imprisonment or the death penalty.

The judge’s decision allowed the hearing to continue without changing the scheduled sentencing proceedings.

Who Was Steven Cozzi and Why Was He Killed?

Steven Cozzi was a 41-year-old Florida attorney who disappeared from his workplace in March 2023.

At the time, Cozzi was involved in civil litigation connected to several clients who were engaged in a legal dispute with Kosowski. Prosecutors argued that the conflict provided a motive for the killing.

According to the prosecution’s case, Kosowski attacked Cozzi inside a bathroom at the attorney’s law office before removing his body from the building.

Investigators presented evidence suggesting that a cart was used to transport the body out of the office before it was placed inside a pickup truck.

Also Read:  Will Yemen wreak havoc on the Houthis? The President declared war, saying- he would liberate the occupied lands

Prosecutors further alleged that Kosowski disposed of Cozzi’s remains in a dumpster. Despite extensive searches of a nearby landfill, investigators have never recovered the attorney’s body.

The prosecution relied on forensic evidence, surveillance footage and digital records to establish its account of what happened.

How Tomasz Kosowski Was Convicted Without a Jury Trial

One of the most unusual aspects of the case was Kosowski’s decision to represent himself in court.

The former plastic surgeon dismissed his court-appointed defense attorneys before the trial and chose to act as his own lawyer. He also waived his right to a jury trial, leaving Judge Bulone responsible for determining whether the prosecution had proved the murder charge.

The trial began in September 2026 and lasted several days as prosecutors presented their evidence.

On September 23, Bulone found Kosowski guilty of first-degree murder. The judge rejected his arguments challenging the prosecution’s version of events.

During his closing argument, Kosowski questioned how prosecutors could establish that Cozzi had been killed when his body had never been recovered.

He also challenged the timeline and physical evidence presented during the proceedings. However, the judge ultimately found the evidence sufficient to establish guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

Also Read:  Israel retaliates, killing Hamas assassin who kidnapped women 3 years ago

Why Special Counsel Was Appointed for the Death Penalty Hearing

Although Kosowski continued representing himself during the penalty phase, he declined to present mitigating evidence or make a substantial effort to argue against the death penalty.

Because the case involved a possible execution, Judge Bulone appointed special counsel to independently investigate and present circumstances that could support a life sentence instead.

The appointed attorney presented information about Kosowski’s background, education, medical career and personal history.

The special counsel also identified circumstances that could be considered in favor of a lesser sentence.

Despite acknowledging these mitigating factors, the judge concluded that they did not outweigh the seriousness and circumstances of the murder.

What Happens Next After Tomasz Kosowski’s Death Sentence?

Kosowski’s sentencing does not mean the legal proceedings are immediately over.

Florida law provides for automatic review of death sentences by the Florida Supreme Court. The review process examines the conviction and death sentence under applicable legal standards.

Judge Bulone also appointed a public defender to handle Kosowski’s appellate proceedings.

The appointment gives Kosowski legal representation for the next stage of the case, following his decision to represent himself during the trial and penalty phase.

The November 20 ruling brings the trial court proceedings to a significant stage, but the case will continue through the appeals process.

Enjoy reading Speaks Media?

Follow us on Google for the latest news.

Leave a Comment